Best Car Picks For Teens & New Drivers

December 29, 2022

If you have a teen (or soon-to-be driver) at home, it's time to start thinking about a good first vehicle. From safety features and price to reliability and insurance, there's a lot to consider. But don't worry! We're here to help start your search with top safety picks and recommendations from the pros.

Safety Really Is #1!

No matter how long you've been on the road, driving comes with risks. For new drivers (and especially teens), safety really is the first priority. Here are some numbers to think about from  the CDC  & the  Insurance Institute for Highway Safety  (IIHS):

  • Only older people drive more than teens, but the risk of a crash is higher among teens 16-19 than any other age group.

  • Teens 16-19 have a fatal crash rate  almost three times as high  as drivers over the age of 20 per mile driven.
  • Crash risk is particularly high during the first months of licensure.
  • In 2020, car crashes were one of the leading causes of death in teens 13-19.

While there's no one best car for everyone,  safety, reliability, and affordability  should be at the forefront of any search.

What To Avoid

While your new driver will likely have their own ideas about what makes an ideal vehicle, make sure to steer clear of super-tiny cars that will get flattened by full-size vehicles, as well as huge trucks and SUVs that are harder to handle and use more gas.

Sports cars and high-horsepower vehicles are also on the "skip" list, because they are easy for inexperienced drivers to crash and much more expensive to insure.

Look For 2013 & Newer Models

The general rule is that newer cars have better safety features. Starting in 2013, vehicles must have the "Big Three" safety features: anti-lock brakes,  traction control, and  stability control. If your budget allows, look for 2018 or later vehicles. This is when vehicles were mandated to have rearview cameras (although you can find them in some cars before then).

Check The Trim & Safety Specs

It's important to remember that not all safety features available come standard with every model or trim level.

​When you're researching makes and models, review the different trim levels to ensure the vehicle you're eyeing comes with the exact safety features you want. 

Car Buying In Today's Market

If you have even  thought  about shopping for cars right now, you already know how challenging it can be to get exactly what you want. Supply issues and rising costs make it hard to find exactly what you're looking for in your budget. Things like color may need to be an afterthought in order to get the features you want. And when you do find a reliable, affordable vehicle, move fast... it may not be on the lot for very long.

And Now... Car Recommendations!

The good news is that there are a  lot  of makes and models of used cars that come highly recommended.  Kelly Blue Book  and  Insurance Institute for Highway Safety  have lists that break out different budgets, model years, features, and body styles.


Here are our selections that take top prizes for reliability, safety, and affordability. (And be sure to check KBB & IIHS out for more picks!)

Honda Accord

The Honda Accord is one of the most widely recommended & safest used car options for beginners. Featuring a sleek look, the Honda Accord marries parental concerns and a teen’s desire for an attractive ride. The Accord is a frequent winner of KBB’s Best Buy Award in the Midsize Sedan category, plus it’s been an IIHS top safety pick every year since 2013.

Mazda 3

With an estimated 35 mpg on the highway and excellent scores in every crash test from IIHS and NHTSA, it's tough to beat the Mazda 3. This vehicle boasts a wide range of safety features, plus sleek and sporty styling in both sedan and hatchback body types.

Toyota RAV4

The Toyota RAV4 is a domestic bestseller that you’ll see on just about every road. Why? Because it’s one of the safest cars out there. It gets great gas mileage, has a roomy interior, and includes responsive handling, especially around corners. The RAV4 consistently earns the top safety marks from the IIHS.

Honda CR-V

The Honda CR-V has a reputation for being a reliable starter vehicle with easy handling. A favorite among compact SUVs, the CR-V is economical with gas and comes with a host of advanced safety features. The CR-V has earned IIHS safety awards since 2015. With seating for 5 and tons of cargo space, this is a great pick for teens!

Mazda CX-5

The Mazda CX-5 has built up a winning reputation for responsive handling, steadiness on the road, overall reliability, and decent fuel economy. The Touring trim comes loaded with advanced safety and driver-assist features. In 2014, the Mazda CX-5 was one of the IIHS’s top safety picks, so those earlier models are still some of the safest used cars out there.

Toyota Corolla

The Toyota Corolla is a mainstay in the compact car segment. This sedan is known for great durability and reliability and is a Top Safety Pick. It's comfortable and easy to drive, and Toyota has packed the Corolla with loads of standard equipment including even more features on higher trim packages.

More Faves From KBB & IIHS:

  • Chevrolet Equinox 

  • Chevrolet Volt

  • Ford C-Max Hybrid

  • Ford Fusion

  • Ford Taurus

  • Honda Civic 

  • Honda Element 

  • Honda Insight

  • Honda Pilot

  • Hyundai Genesis

  • Hyundai Kona

  • Kia Soul 

  • Kia Sportage 

  • Lincoln MKZ

  • Mazda 6

  • Mazda CX-3

  • Nissan Altima

  • Nissan Rogue

  • Subaru Crosstek

  • Subaru Impreza

  • Subaru Legacy

  • Subaru Outback

  • Toyota Avalon

  • Toyota Camry 

  • Toyota Highlander 

  • Toyota Prius 

  • Volkswagen Jetta

  • Volkswagen Passat

  • Volvo S60

  • Volvo XC60

We are wishing you and your family a safe and happy New Year! If you have a new driver to add in near future, we encourage you to reach out as soon as possible so we can help you plan and find the best rates. 

LW Short Agents can help advise you on the best policies to consider, discounts and bundles, and also provide some car-shopping tips to lower the rates for your new driver. Call our office at  843-357-7493  or visit us online at  homeautoinsurancesc.com !

Quote

Get a Quote

At , securing your future is easy. Ready to protect what matters? Contact us for a quick quote and personalized insurance options!

Chat With Us

Chat With Us

Chat with Kelly to gather your info, helping our agents find the best carriers and quotes.

Phone

Call Us

For any inquiries or support, feel free to reach out to us at any time. We're here to assist you!

Contact Us

Send Us a Message

Send a message with your name, email, phone number, and the insurance type you're seeking.

Personal Insurance

Personal Insurance

From auto and homeowners to renters and umbrella policies, we help protect your family and property. Let’s find coverage that fits your life.

Commercial Insurance

Commercial Insurance

We customize policies for your industry's risks, like general liability and workers' comp, ensuring you can run your business worry-free.

Contact L. W. Short Insurance Agency

11945 Grandhaven Drive, STE H, Murrells Inlet, South Carolina 29576, United States

Share this article

Recent Posts

Woman driving a car on a palm-lined road at sunset, with a phone and papers clipped to the window
By LW Short Insurance Agency July 8, 2026
SR-22 insurance in South Carolina is required for 3 years after a DUI or serious violation. Here's what it costs, how to file, and how to find the cheapest SR-22 rate in SC.
Smiling person stands by an ocean pier shop with a ferris wheel and boardwalk in the background
By LW Short Insurance Agency July 7, 2026
A BOP bundles general liability and commercial property into one policy, typically cheaper than buying separately. Here's what it covers for Myrtle Beach small businesses and what it costs.
Customer and barista exchanging a drink at a bright café counter, with pastries and sidewalk seating visible.
By LW Short Insurance Agency July 6, 2026
General liability insurance in South Carolina starts at $400–$800/year for low-risk businesses. Here's what it covers, who needs it, what it costs, and how it compares to a BOP.